Wood Chippers for Small Tractors
Fall 2005

Chipper on BX-22

Opinions/mistakes are mine alone;
your mileage may vary.
© 2005 BEK/Wolfeel/Woolfield

For several years I've rented 6" (or larger) hydraulic feed/trailer mounted wood chippers (like this) to deal with the piles of hawthorn and chokecherry trees/trimmings I seem to accumulate every year. A 6" chipper costs about $200/day to rent in my area. The last chipper I rented had a crapped out hydraulic feed unit (feed quit when the fluid got too hot); the next-to-the last chipper wanted to throw the drive belt if it wasn't engaged ever-so-carefully. And then there is the delay to pick up the chipper (while the counter clerk has his coffee & boots up his computer) and the need to quit a little early to gas it up before returning it to the yard....

Anyway, I've looked for a small wood chipper for my Kubota BX-22 for about a year. The BX-22 is a "sub-compact" tractor. It delivers 16.7 hp at the standard 540 rpm rear PTO, but has a smallish cat. "1" 3 point hitch with somewhat limited 3 point lift capacity. Hydraulic flow at the rear auxiliary of this tractor is too low to power a hydraulic feed chipper.

Small chippers I've investigated come in two basic types: chipper/shredders and straight wood chippers.

Chipper/shredders typically have a rotating drum holding a number of internal swinging hammers or knives. One end of the drum is a built-up flywheel with chipping knives mounted against slots in the flywheel. The drum is usually belted up to run at about 3x the tractor PTO of 540 rpm. See a diagram here.
To use a chipper shredder you drop small stuff (usually up to about 1.5" in diameter) in the top; the swinging knives in the drum grab it and work it over. Stuff bigger than ~1.5" in diameter gets put into a chute on the side of the machine; the chute guides this material against the chipping knives mounted on the flywheel end of the drum.
There is a plate or grate below the drum that sizes what can fall through. Material stays in the drum until it is small enough to fall through the grate and out the bottom. Usually this grate can be changed out to control the size of the chipped/shredded material.
Chipper/shredder Advanages:

  • material sizes from twigs and leaves up to 4"-5" are accommodated by one unit
  • shredder function is truly "self feeding": drop it in the top and it's gone
  • the best choice for lots of leaves, twigs, stalks, and very small stuff
Disadvantages:
  • somewhat mechanically complex, usually meaning heavier and more expensive
  • most units just drop the chips out the bottom of the machine; some units have add-on blowers (at the price of more required horsepower, more complexity, and more $$)
  • often more expensive than straight chippers for a given maximum material size
  • maximum diameter capacity is limited: usually 4" or less (some units accept 5")

Chippers usually have a heavy flywheel spun in a housing by the tractor's PTO. There are slots in the flywheel and chipping knives mounted to the face of the flywheel adjacent to the slots (like this). Material is put in a chute that directs it against the knives. Chips cut from the end of the material fly through the flywheel slot and are blown out a chute by vanes attached to the back of the flywheel.
"Classic" PTO chippers are direct-drive from the tractor's PTO: their flywheels run at ~540 rpm. "Classic" PTO chippers need heavy flywheels (100 lbs or more is common) to store energy between knife cuts and so even out the load on the tractor's engine.
In the last few years there have appeared PTO chippers with smaller, lighter flywheels belted up to run at higher rpms like the drums of chipper/shredders. Energy storage in these chippers can be nearly that of classic chippers with heavy flywheels, but the units themselves can be smaller and lighter, and often require less horsepower to run.
To run a PTO chipper you drop small stuff or insert larger stuff into the intake chute. If well designed, PTO chippers will aggressively "self feed" 1" or 2" (or larger) continuous material. Leafy branches will feed until the branch gets too twiggy and leafy; the remainder of the branch just sits in the chute waiting to be pushed in by the next branch.
Most chippers (like chipper/shredders) have reversible/resharpenable chipper knives. Many units chip against a bed knife that can be adjusted to somewhat control chip size.
Chipper Advanages:

  • simple design and operation
  • most units blow chips "automatically", without add-ons
  • high(er) rpm units can be small(er), light(er), and require less horsepower
  • can be less expensive than chipper/shredders for the same rated maximum size material
Disadvanages:
  • usually will not "self feed" just small stuff: you need a mixture of solid 1" plus diameter stuff to help feed the small stuff
  • maximum diameter capacity is limited by the horsepower delivered by small tractors (usually 4" or less)
  • high(er) rpm units more complex (but still simpler than chipper/shredders)

I have examined and/or demoed these chipper/shredders:

  • Harper Goossen CS5400 PTO
    In my opinion the pick in this category in terms of design and construction, but weighs 560 lbs and would cost $3,090 + $150 freight + tax from a local tractor dealer (price quoted 8/2005, before negotiation). 18-25 hp required, max. size material = 5"
  • Crary BearCat 5" Chipper/Shredder
    Weighs 450 lbs; 13-40 hp required; max. size material = 5". Cost: ~$2,600
  • Woods Equipment Model 5000
    Made by BearCat; more expensive in my area than the BearCat
  • Mackissic TPH-122/TPH-183 (go to "MightyMac" then "Three Point Hitch")
    The TPH122 seemed a little light weight to me at 282 lbs; 10-30 hp required; max. size material = 3.5". Cat. "0" or 1 hitch (good for a very small tractor). Cost: $1,399.99 + freight from Northern Tool
    TPH183: more solid than the TPH122; weighs 460 lbs; 16-45 hp required; max. size material = 4.5". Cost: ~$2,700 (2006) + freight from Northern Tool
    Several tractorbynet.com posters like these machines.

I have examined and/or demoed these chippers:

  • Valby CH140F
    Made in Finland. Super heavy duty and capable. Self feeds very effectively. I would have purchased this chipper if price was no object (in 2002 this chipper cost ~$2,800 in the US).
    Weighs 585 lbs (220 lb flywheel); 15-40 hp required; 540-1,000 rpm required; runs at 540-1,000 rpm; 2 knives; max. size material = 6.25" rotating exhaust chute; hydraulic feed can be added.
  • Wallenstein BX40
    A great alternative in a "classic" chipper to the Valby CH140. Weighs 400 lbs; 16-40 hp required; runs at 540 rpm; 3 knives; max. size material = 4".
    2006 Update:
    This model seems to have been replaced by the BX42.
  • Salsco Model 600
    An impressive "high speed" chipper, very well built. See more pictures here. The newest Model 600 I saw had a double belt pulley instead of the single belt pictured on the company's website. This chipper self feeds very effectively because of the especially steep intake chute; however, I did not like the steep angle so well. It felt less natural to me to lift material up over the lip of the chute. I think this chipper is an excellent value for the money; I almost bought one. Weighs 388 lbs; 8-40 hp required; runs at ~1,800 rpm; 2 knives; max. size material = 3.5". Cost: $1,750 (quoted by Salsco 8/2005)
  • Pequea Machine, Inc. Champion C-3
    This is the chipper I bought. See more pictures here. Simple mechanics, heavy construction. I believe this chipper weighs well over 400 lbs (instead of the quoted weight of 350 lbs). I like the angle, size, and arrangement of the loading chute; I especially like the fold-down cover that becomes a shelf (like the bigger 6" chippers I have rented). Three year old 3" hawthorn feeds smoothly and continuously into this chipper. Simple and easy to maintain. Exhaust chute reverses from side to side, but does not rotate. The chipper base has slots cut for loader forks (too bad my Kubota doesn't have a quick-detach bucket system so that I could easily mount forks!).
    Quoted weight is 350 lbs (I think 400+ lbs); 15-30 hp required; runs at 3.3x tractor PTO speed (~1,800+ rpm); 2 knives; max. size material = 3". Cost: ~$2,500
    I bought this chipper new from the manufacturer at the 2005 NY State Farm Days ag show; I paid less than the list price quoted for the Salsco 600 (above).
  • Woods Equipment TCH4500
    I saw this chipper (made for Woods by BearCat) at the the 2005 NY State Farm Days ag show. Nicely designed, with a large folding load chute. Belt driven, with a manual lever to tension the belt (i.e., this chipper has a clutch independent of the tractor's PTO clutch). The end of the flywheel shaft is exposed in its housing, and is painted so that it's easy to see if the shaft is rotating. The shroud for the flywheel is slightly elongated upward with a nice big lifting hole near the center of balance of the chipper: easy to sling this machine to move it. Disadvantage: chips are exhausted downward to one side only (wouldn't take long until you have to shovel them aside). This chipper seemed expensive to me at the quoted price.
    Weighs 600 lbs; 8-40 hp required; runs at ~1,800 rpm; 4 knives; max. size material = 4.5". Cost: $3,250 (quoted by Woods 8/2005)
  • NOTE: I did not consider the Jinma Model 4 Mechanical-feed Chipper from China, despite (generally) favorable reviews I've seen for the Model 6. The Model 4 (4" capacity) seems to cost almost as much as the Model 6 (6" capacity), and most dealers offer only the Model 6 (which is too heavy for my BX-22 at ~780 lbs).
Champion C-3 | Woods TCH4500 | Salsco 600 | Split-Fire Chippers | Honda H5013 Tractor
* End of this page *